When a family disagreement turns into a court case over a will, a trust, or an estate, the attorney you choose shapes how the case is handled from the first letter to the final hearing. This guide explains the kinds of disputes probate litigation covers in Florida, the deadlines that can come up early, and practical questions to ask before you hire a lawyer in Naples or elsewhere in Collier County.
If you already have a dispute, see our Naples probate litigation page or call 239-963-2897.
What probate litigation covers
Probate litigation is a contested matter in, or connected to, a probate or trust administration. Common examples in Florida include:
- Will contests. These are challenges to a will based on lack of capacity, undue influence, fraud, duress, or improper signing. (See Florida will contest requirements.)
- Trust disputes. Examples include challenges to a trust or a late amendment, and claims that a trustee breached a fiduciary duty. (See challenging a suspicious trust amendment and trustee breach of fiduciary duty.)
- Personal representative disputes. These include requests to remove a personal representative, objections to accountings, and surcharge claims for mismanaged assets. (See removing a Florida personal representative.)
- Beneficiary and heir disputes. These cover how a will or trust should be read, who inherits, and how assets should be divided.
- Spousal and homestead issues. A surviving spouse may have rights under Florida law that affect how property passes.
Deadlines can be short
Probate disputes often come with deadlines that are easy to miss. For example, under section 733.212(3), Florida Statutes, an interested person who is served with a notice of administration generally must object to the validity of the will, the venue, or the court’s jurisdiction within 3 months after service. Otherwise those objections are barred. Other deadlines apply to creditor claims, trust contests, and objections to accountings.
Because of this, it helps to speak with a lawyer as soon as you receive court papers or a notice from a personal representative or trustee.
What to look for in a probate litigation attorney
1. Focus on probate and trust disputes. Ask how much of the lawyer’s practice involves contested probate and trust matters, and whether the lawyer also handles routine probate administration. Knowing both sides of an estate can help in spotting problems in an inventory, an accounting, or a set of estate planning documents.
2. Courtroom and appellate experience. Some probate disputes settle, and others go to an evidentiary hearing or trial. Some go on to appeal. Ask whether the lawyer handles hearings and trials, and whether the lawyer handles appeals.
3. Familiarity with the local court. Probate matters in Collier County are heard in the Twentieth Judicial Circuit. A lawyer who regularly practices there knows the local procedures and scheduling.
4. Clear communication. You should come away from a consultation understanding the main issues, the likely next steps, and what information the lawyer needs from you. Ask how you will receive updates and who you will be talking to.
5. Transparent fees. Ask how fees are charged (hourly, flat fee, or another arrangement), what costs to expect, and whether attorney’s fees might be paid from the estate or trust, or awarded by the court, in your type of case.
6. An honest assessment. Be cautious of anyone who promises a particular result. A good first meeting covers the strengths and weaknesses of your position, the costs, and alternatives such as mediation.
Questions to ask at a consultation
- What are the deadlines in my situation, and has any of them already started to run?
- What documents should I gather? For example, the will or trust, prior versions, the notice of administration, accountings, and bank or medical records.
- Is mediation likely, and when?
- What is a realistic timeline?
- How will fees and costs be handled?
Gathering documents before you meet
Bring what you have: the will or trust and any amendments, court papers you have received, letters from the personal representative or trustee, account statements, and a short timeline of key events. Do not destroy or alter any records, even if they seem unfavorable.
About Brantley Oakey
The Law Office of Brantley Oakey is a Naples law practice that handles probate, probate litigation, trust disputes, estate planning, and civil litigation. Brantley Oakey has been a member of The Florida Bar since 2012. He graduated magna cum laude from Brigham Young University-Idaho and cum laude from Ave Maria School of Law, where he was a senior editor of the law review.
His appellate work includes Florida Citizens Alliance v. School Board of Collier County, a Sunshine Law appeal decided by the Second District Court of Appeal; the Florida Supreme Court declined review. In 2022 he received a Special Recognition of Merit from the Florida Citizens’ Alliance for that appeal.
To talk about a will contest, trust dispute, or personal representative issue, call 239-963-2897 or visit our probate litigation page. The office is at 780 5th Avenue South, Ste 200, Naples, FL 34102.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Comments
2 responses to “How to Choose a Naples Probate Litigation Attorney”
[…] inheritance, but it can also be expensive and emotionally draining when evidence is weak. A prompt case assessment provides the clearest path forward. The Law Office of Brantley Oakey can evaluate the probate […]
[…] focused consultation with a probate litigation attorney can clarify whether the facts justify a petition, what evidence is missing, and whether removal, an […]